Payment Options

Automated Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)

Automated funds transfer from your bank to Main Street America Insurance is the easy, low-maintenance way to pay your monthly bill. Enroll today and never worry about missing a payment again. Plus, you’ll save on postage and up to $72 per year in installment fees.

To sign up, complete the enrollment form in My Account or contact your independent agent for details.

Online Payment

Make a payment online 24/7.

Pay today or schedule a payment for a future date through the Pay Your Bill link below. Choose from one of the following payment methods:

Visa®, MasterCard®, Discover® and American Express® credit or debit cards
Checking or Savings Account
PayPal® and PayPal Credit*
Venmo®*

PAY YOUR BILL

Note: Up to a $4.95 fee per payment may be assessed.

* PayPal, PayPal Credit, and Venmo are available to most customers. It may not be available in your area.

Phone Payment

Call (866) 335-0509 to pay your bill using our automated phone service. Please have your account or policy number and payment information ready to pay by debit card, credit card, or checking or savings account.

Additional Options

Banking or Billpay Service

Make a payment electronically through a financial institution or billpayer service of your choice.

Mail Payment

To mail a payment, tear off the stub from your billing statement and enclose a check or money order in the return envelope you received. Please write your account or policy number in the memo line.

Mail your payment to:

Main Street America Insurance
Attn: Premium Services
55 West Street Keene, N.H. 03431-3373

Payment or Billing Questions

Still have questions about your payment or bill? Your independent agent is ready to help make the billing and payment process as easy and seamless as possible. Their name and number are located on your billing statement and policy. Get in touch today.

Hear from our customers

“I have numerous success stories where claims were handled in such a professional way that clients become customers for life. ”

Mathieu Steele

Agent - Stan Steele Agency

“We believe Main Street America shares many of the same values and truly respects the relationship between the agency and partnering carrier, as well as recognizes and gives back to the communities in which they operate. ”

Brian Daubert

Agent - PayneWest Insurance

“We can always reach an underwriter by phone and get an immediate response. In fact, all of the Main Street America employees we interact with are very helpful and return our calls and emails promptly. ”

George Abbott

Agent - Abbott Insurance Agency

“Whether it is a policy or billing question, Main Street America is always willing to go the extra mile to help answer or resolve the issue. ”

Lora Wehrmann

Agent - Eastern Shore Insurance

“Main Street America has a great willingness to listen and we can always talk with them and get things done. We get very good service and resolution. ”

Kent Spain

Agent - Suffolk Insurance Corporation

“Working with Main Street America is a pleasure. We are truly mutually aligned in our goals for a successful partnership. ”

Doug Bishop

Agent - Bouchard Insurance

“One of the things we love about Main Street America is that our success is the result of teamwork and the strong personal relationships we have developed. ”

Mary Ellen Gullickson

Agent - The Pilzer-Gullickson Group