Skip to main content

Why Partner with Main Street America?

Partner Take Care image

We take care of our customers (that’s you) better than anyone else.

We offer dedicated support from our customer service, claims, sales and underwriting teams, as well as a competitive compensation package that’s one of the best in the industry.

Partner Financial Strength image

We have proven financial strength and longevity.

$1.1 billion direct written premium | $2.61 billion total assets | “A” (“Excellent”) financial strength rating “a+” issuer credit rating

Partner Committed image

We’re committed to serving independent agents: our future is you.

We believe in the value you bring your policyholders. We’re developing new technologies, expanding product offerings, and leveraging our full resources to help you achieve profitable growth.

Partner Growth image

We’re growing and we want you to be a part of it.

It’s an exciting time to join Main Street America. We’re expanding our footprint, developing new products, and deploying cutting-edge technology to provide you with streamlined, easy-to-use platforms.

A Message From Our CEO

From our financial strength to our commitment to serve independent agents, Main Street America Insurance is here to serve you and your clients better than anyone else.

Learn more from Main Street America's CEO Chris Listau about why you should partner with us.


Our Insurance Products

We believe independent agents deliver the choice, guidance, and support consumers need when searching for personal and commercial insurance. That’s why we offer a full range of products all backed by our by highly responsive customer service, underwriting, and sales service teams.

For Individuals and Families

Our range of individual insurance products include personal Auto, Flood, Home, Renters, Condo, Landlord, and Umbrella. We have the full line of protection that your clients need, plus insurance discounts — from Accident Free to Multi-Product — to provide excellent value.

For Businesses

We've been protecting the people and businesses you'll find on Main Street since 1923. With our financial strength and unwavering commitment to independent agents like you, your clients can do business with peace of mind.

Our business coverages include Business Owners (BOP), Bonds, Contractors, Commercial Auto, Commercial Agribusiness, Flood, Umbrella, and Workers' Compensation.


Who We Are Flyer

Who We Are

Download this flyer to learn more about our mission, history and vision for the future.


Why You'll Love Working With Us

“I didn’t think I’d survive this storm financially but my policy did what it was meant to and got us back to where we were. You were straight with me from the start, and I can’t tell you how rare that is anymore. Thank you!”
Matt Blaisdell
Owner - Shining Spaces Cleaning
“I have numerous success stories where claims were handled in such a professional way that clients become customers for life. ”
Mathieu Steele
Agent - Stan Steele Agency
“We believe Main Street America shares many of the same values and truly respects the relationship between the agency and partnering carrier, as well as recognizes and gives back to the communities in which they operate. ”
Brian Daubert
Agent - PayneWest Insurance
“We can always reach an underwriter by phone and get an immediate response. In fact, all of the Main Street America employees we interact with are very helpful and return our calls and emails promptly. ”
George Abbott
Agent - Abbott Insurance Agency
“Whether it is a policy or billing question, Main Street America is always willing to go the extra mile to help answer or resolve the issue. ”
Lora Wehrmann
Agent - Eastern Shore Insurance
“Main Street America has a great willingness to listen and we can always talk with them and get things done. We get very good service and resolution. ”
Kent Spain
Agent - Suffolk Insurance Corporation
“Working with Main Street America is a pleasure. We are truly mutually aligned in our goals for a successful partnership. ”
Doug Bishop
Agent - Bouchard Insurance
“One of the things we love about Main Street America is that our success is the result of teamwork and the strong personal relationships we have developed. ”
Mary Ellen Gullickson
Agent - The Pilzer-Gullickson Group

Become an Appointed Agent

No numeric values allowed.
Either 5 or 9 numbers.
Example: 12345-6789
10 digit numbers only. Include Area Code. Ex: 1112223333
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Become an Agent image